Hate and Tolerance

“In the practice of tolerance, one’s enemy is the best teacher.”
- the Dalai Lama

Michael and I have a very long conversation after his post about spirituality and love and hate. Michael’s recent post has naturally caused its own degree of uproar, I expected as much, and not unjustly. If the a church (LDS or not) had given money to try to remove womens’ rights or black rights would we be having this conversation or would people see that as hate? The bibles might say that being gay is bad but it also has a ton of other rules people do not follow, for example we do not execute brides who are not virgins (Deuteronomy 22:13-21) nor are widows who’s husbands died before they can have children forced to be impregnated by the late husband’s brothers (Mark 12:18-27) thank goodness right? Anyhow, the purpose of this post it not to discuss the bible or gay rights.

I think the 14th Dalai Lama is an amazing man and his teachings ring true to my soul. I try to let his teachings on compassion be the foundation of my actions towards others. It is really hard to not give into negative feelings regarding others. It is so easy to hate. It would be so easy to be angry at Michael’s parents for their intolerant views, it would be so easy to be angry at Michael for wanting to cut of ties with them. It would be so easy to be angry at the LDS church for opposing gay rights and funneling money into a political movement (something I see as hate speech and a violation of the seperation of church and state.) Sometimes I want to hate the people who hate.

But I can’t. I know I cannot steer anyone’s mind towards tolerance with hate and anger, that can only be accomplished through compassion and love.

Michael’s parents are good people, Michael is a good person, but I have to recognize that there is a lot of history here. 21 years of history before I ever met or moved in with Michael. Michael’s whole family, as far as I know, are Mormon. Michael, their eldest son, is not, he left the church. Anyone who comes from a family like this knows what kind of tension this causes, though I thought this tension has lessened over time. When I moved in with Michael, I became the bridge between him and his family. I think this gay rights thing is the hair that broke the camels back.

Now the question arises, how can I address this situation with compassion. It would be easy to take sides. To be honest, I am not exactly sure what I am going to do right now. What is easy and what is right are unfortunately not always the same thing. At the moment, I have chosen to support Michael’s decision and mostly stay out of the matter. I have to have faith in his decision regarding his family and I have to trust he made it for the good of our son.

Gay issues rarely come up in family discussions but when it does the words do fly. Do I want Damian in an environment like that? There is a fine line between debating and fighting. I learned a long time ago to tune out fighting, so maybe I missed this building up. Last month at the family potluck Michael and his mother debated about civil liberties, it did not end on a good note because they couldn’t find common ground. The overtone of the argument was morals and seperation of church and state.

I love my in laws. I will not keep them from seeing their grandson or myself but I will also not go out of my way to meet up with them, until I figure out where I stand on this issue. Heart and head are not agreeing at the moment. Where does one draw the line between accepting someone for who they are and condoning negative behavior? Should you give more leniency to family then others?

Some people have asked if we would keep Damian from having friends with hateful views, and while I would hope he would have better sense then to run with people like that, I would not (unless they were drug dealers or something, always extenuating circumstances.) However this question is not relevant at the moment, Damian is a baby, not a child in school. The question is, so should I shelter him from anger, arguments and hate right now, in these early most formative years?

The Dalai Lama has said “The ultimate authority must always rest with the individual’s own reason and critical analysis.” This is a very complex issue, one that I know won’t blow over. I know I must tread lightly and think deeply. Until then I am using the advice my mother has offered me since I was a child. If you have nothing nice to say don’t say anything at all. So for now I am just going to try stay out of this, which admittedly is not the easiest thing for me to do!

7 Comments

  1. gesh
    Posted Monday, November 17, 2008 at 1:09 pm | Permalink

    I love your introspective nature. You will do the right thing. In the end babies thrive from people around them who love them. And if Person A loves him and believes this way and person B loves him and believes that way. He’s loved. And everyone’s ego should be pushed aside for that. Babies don’t know agenda. Babies don’t know politics or religion. Babies know hugs and coos and tickles.

  2. Posted Monday, November 17, 2008 at 1:15 pm | Permalink

    And diaper changes… ;-) Thanks for the vote of confidence, I really appreciate it.

  3. Posted Monday, November 17, 2008 at 7:14 pm | Permalink

    You’re right, the right thing is usually not the easy thing. Hang in there. I hope you guys get it sorted out.

  4. Posted Tuesday, November 18, 2008 at 5:32 am | Permalink

    I am so sad to read the last two posts and feel very badly for Damian and the entire family. Fighting intolerance with intolerance cannot help but cause wars and divisions. I hope an unconditional healing of relationships will happen soon. I pray you will have the wisdom to facilitate this.
    Much love……..

  5. Dad
    Posted Friday, November 21, 2008 at 4:22 pm | Permalink

    I agree with Ruth. Only giving love and understanding will work.
    Do not approach your beliefs/convictions with negative feelings.
    Love All, Serve All.
    Michael needs to move on, and Damian needs all of his family in order to grow as a person.
    I should know ……….

  6. Chad
    Posted Tuesday, December 2, 2008 at 6:16 pm | Permalink

    Good old religion and politics, its no wonder those topics are good ones to avoid in many situations. Perhaps that just needs to be the rule when going to see your inlaws.

    I feel for you and Michael in this situation as well as Michael’s parents. Its got to be hard for you all. Tension is never fun to deal with. My advice is to continue to support your husband since thats who you are closest too, but slowly help him realize that to truly teach your child tolerance you must be an example of it and tolerate his parents as well no matter what there views are, otherwise he is no different then what he believes they are.

    You make a good point of how much should we tolerate others. Should we tolerate someone who is a drug dealer as our friends? Or perhaps someone who just does drugs? Should we tolerate a murderer as our friend? Should we tolerate those who are racist as our friends? How about those that dislike the current president?

    All good questions, I think we each must answer these for ourselves. My answer to them is tolerate them all, no matter what they do or have done or believe. Hopefully I’m doing a good job at teaching my kids the same view. Its not for us to judge others situations. Maybe that murderer really is innocent or it was self defense or they are completely different now. I admit my view may be a bit extreme, there is a line that you have to watch out for ones life. In other words I do try to avoid those I think would be dangerous to my family physically. Mentally however If we encounter someone I disagree with when they leave I use them as an example of how not to think and why. Or even just agree to disagree and hopefully never talk about it again. This is just my view though everyone is different and needs to decide for themselves what they can handle. Unfortunately as parents we have the huge task to decide that for our children as well, hopefully one day they will grow up and thank us, but if not at least one day they will hopefully forgive us.

  7. Loretta Tolman
    Posted Monday, December 8, 2008 at 12:36 pm | Permalink

    Tolerance works two ways. Mom